A Tradition of Service

At Schuetz Insurance, we worry about our customers, not our competition. That means we stick to what made us successful in the first place: hard work, strong relationships, and an unwavering commitment to customer service. Call them Midwestern values if you want; we like to say it’s doing insurance the right way.

Our Past, Influencing the Present

1943

Renting an office in the old Knights of Pythias Flatiron Building, Maurice J. Schuetz, Sr., an experienced surety bond underwriter, forms the M.J. Schuetz Agency in downtown Indianapolis, helping protect the construction companies working to build a better Midwest.

1957

It’s a family affair: Maurice J. Schuetz, Jr. becomes the second full-time employee, joining his father and his mother, who worked part-time for the previous 14 years. Their son-in-law, DV Pace, would also join three years later.

1969

The M.J. Schuetz Agency moves from the Knights of Pythias Flatiron Building to the Fidelity Building (Salesforce Tower).

1975

The agency moves again, this time occupying the fifth floor of the Circle Tower Building, located right on Monument Circle.

2012

After years of growth, the agency is purchased by long-term employees Vickie L. Wolcott and David A. Linthicum, changing the name of the agency to M.J. Schuetz Insurance Services, Inc.

2015

M.J. Schuetz is named Agency of the Year by the Independent Insurance Agents of Indiana.

2021

After 45+ years and even greater company growth, M.J. Schuetz leaves the fifth floor of the Circle Tower Building for the modernized office space in 16-tech.

2022

M.J. Schuetz Insurance Services, Inc. launches a new website, rebrands as Schuetz Insurance, and wins Agency of the Year once more.

Our Present, Influencing the Future

With a state-of-the-art facility, a staff of almost 40 with over 200+ years of combined experience in the insurance industry, and an ever-expanding catalog of coverage and services, we might not look like the same mom-and-pop agency that started in 1943. But rest assured, the principles that guided Maurice J. Schuetz, Sr. in 1943 are the same principles that guide us today. Every move and expansion we make is done with our customers in mind, giving us the tools we need to offer better services to you in a way that would make Mr. Schuetz proud. As we like to say, we may adjust with the times, but we’ll never change.

Our Office

Meet

The Schuetz Team

Dave Linthicum

President

Mike Corcoran

Vice President - Sales

Stella Milli

Vice President - Commercial Lines

Jenni Waggoner

Vice President - Surety

Pamela Christianson

Vice President - Personal Lines

Leah Correthers

Human Resources

Join Our Family

We don’t use the term lightly. M.J. Schuetz founded the agency with his family, and we look to carry on that tradition. We might not be blood, but we are bonded in our commitment to our community, our customers, and each other.

View Open Positions